Skip to main content
21 votes
Accepted

Are there differences in accuracy and reliability between the frozen phonon method and Density Functional Perturbation Theory?

Short answer: Modern implementations of these two methods lead to similar accuracies. Longer answer: The calculation of phonons requires the calculation of the Hessian of the potential energy surface ...
ProfM's user avatar
  • 11.1k
14 votes
Accepted

Reliability about the predicted two-dimensional crystal structures based on DFT high-throughput calculation?

[Disclaimer - I am one of the co-authors of the 2D database on Materials Cloud (What you call "2D structures and layered materials", publishing the data of this work: N. Mounet et al., ...
Giovanni Pizzi's user avatar
10 votes
Accepted

Why do we need to build a supercell to use the DFPT in Phonopy interfaced with VASP?

Disclaimer: I have never used Phonopy. The advantage of using DFPT is that in principle it can be used to calculate a perturbation of finite wave vector $\mathbf{q}$ using the primitive cell. This ...
ProfM's user avatar
  • 11.1k
9 votes
Accepted

How to improve a phonon spectrum calculation for a monolayer material?

This is actually an important question regardless of the code you're using (I use SIESTA and NWChem). To obtain a good phonon spectrum, the first thing you need is a truly relaxed/optimized structure. ...
Elie H's user avatar
  • 1,411
7 votes

Phonon calculations using DFPT

WARNING (added by T.S., see comments below) As of 4/17/2024, VASP DFPT only works for $q=\Gamma$, thus you must use a supercell even with VASP-DFPT + Phonopy. Even the phonopy documentation uses a ...
Jaafar Mehrez's user avatar
6 votes
Accepted

What is the importance of electron interaction on dielectric response of crystals?

I think you should take care of all possible interactions to get close to the real picture. In periodic solids, there might be electron-hole interaction (solve BSE equation for it), el-phonon coupling,...
Haseeb Ahmad's user avatar
5 votes
Accepted

DFPT vs analytical nuclear gradient

These are not the same quantity. The gradient of the energy with respect to the position $\vec{R}_i=(x_i,y_i,z_i)$ of atom $i$ gives the force, $\vec{F}_i$, acting on that atom, $$ \vec{F}_i=-\left(\...
Phil Hasnip's user avatar
  • 8,142
4 votes
Accepted

Do the bottom layers of the slab need to be fixed when we use DFPT or finite displacement methods to compute the phonon spectrum of a surface?

No you do not need to. Fixing atoms during a finite displacement or a DFPT calculation is not a real thing. This is a huge approximation that will break the symmetry of the force constant matrix, ...
Okano's user avatar
  • 1,417
4 votes
Accepted

First order variation of the wave function of conduction states

Let's start by unpacking Eq. (1), which we rewrite here: $$\begin{equation} (H_{SCF} - \varepsilon_n)\lvert \Delta \psi_n \rangle = -(\Delta V_{SCF} + \Delta \varepsilon_n) \lvert \psi_n \rangle. \tag{...
elutionary's user avatar
  • 1,006
2 votes

Phonon frequencies and free energy with respect to polymorphs

Your interpretation of the results. I agree with you that if you find no imaginary frequencies in the cubic phase it means it is at a local minimum of the potential energy landscape, and that if you ...
ProfM's user avatar
  • 11.1k
1 vote

Inconsistencies in Phonon Dispersion Results Using Phonopy DFPT with Different Supercell Sizes

Based on your comments above, it looks like you increased k-point sampling for the 3x3x1 supercell and found the correct dispersions. It seems like the imaginary modes in the smaller cells is due to ...
Tyler Sterling's user avatar

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible